Same Old Question


Last week, I was pretty much focused on the situation in Cairo and the millions of people demonstrating for freedom.  Ironically, it was also the 150 year anniversary  of  the Battle of Gettysburg. This was a time in the history of the United States when there was a war for freedom waged between the north and the south. Three days in July 1863 in rural Pennsylvania near the site of a small town Gettysburg became one of the most important battles of that war.LincolnMcC

President Lincoln meeting with his generals.


Here is a photograph of a regiment of Confederate soldiers.

This is the first war documented with  photography.  The South had lead a ferocious war and if it had not been for several mistakes made by General Lee at Gettysburg, the outcome of the war might have been different.  He let his men influence  him against his better judgement not to pursue  the Northern troops as they retreated, and he ordered the fateful Picket’s Charge on day 3 when 1/2 of Picket’s men of 12, 500 were either killed or wounded.  Lee had to retreat and was never to invade the Northern territory again. Later, it was obvious that these three days of battle were the major turning point of the war.

What was the  cause of the Civil War?  President Lincoln said it was to preserve the Union of the United States after the Southern states succeeded. The South said the war was about their rights or States’ Rights to determine their own laws and way of life.  The South was mostly agrarian with large plantations and many acres that were manned by slaves. The North was mainly urban and much more industrial.  Well, the Southern way of life and livelihood would not survive without the slaves . Many plantation owners were unable to live within their means and if the “free” labor given by slaves was taken away, the Southern way of life would be over.  This was the heart of the matter, the future of slavery in our country both in new territories and ultimately in the South.  The question was the  future of cheap or free labor in the South.

Jump  ahead 150 years and guess what?  In the United States the same question of cheap labor is taking place, but in the Capitol in Washington DC.  This time , the question is not slavery but the cheap labor provided by  immigrants from Mexico.  Many of these people are so desperate for  a better life that they risk life and limb to enter our country. At this very time, the House and Senate are presenting bills to  determine the policy for these people who are already here,and came illegally. What should be done about them, their families and what is the policy for undocumented people in the future? It is a complicated, expensive, and difficult question but it all boils down to  the question of providing the country with cheap labor for jobs Americans seem not to want to do.

Some tough questions stay the same in different context and time.

The desert in Southern Arizona littered by immigrants’ trash while entering the United States on foot.


illegal aliens 2

Vans of workers who often  pay  their life’s savings to the “mule” or driver  who brings them in hot paneled trucks into Arizona or Texas.


Mexican children celebrating Cinco de Mayo, their victory over the French.

“Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” and “freedom and justice for all ” are very strong magnets pulling on the human spirit of  slaves,  Egyptians, Mexicans, or people everywhere.

About annetbell

I am a retired elementary teacher, well seasoned world traveler,new blogger, grandmother, and a new enthusiastic discoverer of the wonderfully complex country of India. Anne
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Same Old Question

  1. OyiaBrown says:

    Reblogged this on Oyia Brown.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.